Advertisement
News

Health Minister criticises NPHET's Nolan for 'snake oil' antigen comments

May 11, 2021 13:15 By Shannonside News
Health Minister criticises NPHET's Nolan for 'snake oil' antigen comments
Share this article

The comments caused concern among people who belive the tests should be used by more health professionals

The Health Minister has criticised NPHET's modeling expert Prof. Philip Nolan for comparing antigen tests to snake oil.

Stephen Donnelly says the comment was unhelpful and antigen testing is a part of government policy when it comes to re-opening. Late last week budget supermarket Lidl began selling antigen test, heavily promoting the take-at-home tests.

In a tweet Professor Philip Nolan, NPHET's main modeling and forecasting expert, compared them to snake oil - saying antigen tests will not keep people safe. NPHET has long had concerns about the effectiveness of antigen testing, which isn't as reliable as PCR tests.

Advertisement

But Health Minister Stephen Donnelly criticised the remarks from Prof Nolan. The government has been promising wider use of antigen testing for months, somewhat held back by the concerns of NPHET.

Advertisement

But the tests will be used in Catherine Martin's trials of big sporting events and gigs.

Advertisement

They've also been discussed for use in the safe return of students to college campuses in September, including in Maynooth where Prof Nolan is University President.

Share this article
Advertisement
Advertisement

Shannonside Newsletter

Sign up now to keep up to date with the latest news.

Processing your request...

You are subscribed now! please check your email to confirm your subscription.

Copyright © 2024 Shannonside FM. Developed by Square1 and Powered by PublisherPlus